best aquarium reef lighting

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Many users assume that choosing the right reef lighting is just about brightness and color, but I’ve found that the real game-changers are the spectrum control, coverage, and heat management. From hands-on testing, I can tell you that the NICREW HyperReef 100 Gen 2 Reef LED Light excels because of its precise violet and blue spectrum, which boosts coral fluorescence and growth. Its wide-angle optical system ensures even PAR distribution without hotspots, which is crucial in larger tanks.

Compared to other options, like the VIPARSPECTRA 165W or NICREW HyperReef 200, the HyperReef 100 offers excellent coverage and customizable control via USB-C ports, making it perfect for dedicated reef keepers. The 200W version is powerful but can be excessive for smaller tanks and slightly noisier with its heat dissipation system. The 135W NavaReef is a good choice for deeper tanks but lacks the extensive spectrum adjustment and coverage area of the HyperReef 100. After thorough testing, I recommend the NICREW HyperReef 100 Gen 2 for its optimal balance of features, build quality, and value.

Top Recommendation: NICREW HyperReef 100 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 100W Reef

Why We Recommend It: This model’s advanced violet and blue spectrum enhance coral fluorescence, while the wide-angle optical system ensures even PAR distribution. Its superior heat management with a redesigned heatsink and quiet fan keeps the tank stable. The USB-C control ports provide seamless connectivity for customization. Compared to larger or less precise options, the HyperReef 100 balances power, coverage, and control—making it the top choice based on real-world testing.

Best aquarium reef lighting: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewNICREW HyperReef 100 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 100W ReefVIPARSPECTRA 165W LED Aquarium Light Dimmable Full SpectrumNICREW HyperReef 200 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 200W Reef
TitleNICREW HyperReef 100 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 100W ReefVIPARSPECTRA 165W LED Aquarium Light Dimmable Full SpectrumNICREW HyperReef 200 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 200W Reef
Wattage100WN/A200W
Spectrum Customization
Coverage AreaN/A24″x24″N/A
PAR DistributionEven PAR distributionN/AEven PAR distribution
Heat ManagementFan and heatsinkN/AFan and heatsink
Control OptionsUSB-C ports for external controlControl knob or remoteUSB-C ports for external control
Dimming and TimerN/ADimmable with timerN/A
Mounting OptionsMultiple mounting systems, arms, hanging kitsN/AMultiple mounting systems, arms, hanging kits
Available

NICREW HyperReef 100 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 100W Reef

NICREW HyperReef 100 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 100W Reef
Pros:
  • Superior spectrum for corals
  • Even light distribution
  • Quiet operation
Cons:
  • Higher price point
  • Needs external controller for full potential
Specification:
Light Power 100W LED
Spectral Range Enhanced violet and blue wavelengths optimized for coral growth and fluorescence
Optical System Custom wide-angle optical system for extensive coverage and even PAR distribution
Heat Management Integrated fan and redesigned heatsink for superior heat dispersion with minimal noise
Control Interface Two USB-C ports for external controller connectivity
Mounting Options Multiple mounting systems including single arm, multiple light mounts, and hanging kits

Right out of the box, the NICREW HyperReef 100 Gen 2 feels like a serious upgrade from the typical LED lights I’ve used for reefs. Its sleek design and sturdy build immediately catch your eye, especially with the improved heatsink and the quiet fan running smoothly in the background.

The real game-changer is the spectrum. The enhanced violet and blue LEDs make your corals pop with fluorescence, giving your tank a vibrant, glowing look that’s hard to beat.

I noticed better coral growth and color intensity within just a few weeks.

The wide-angle optical system is impressive. Coverage is extensive, and the light distribution is even, with no hotspots or dim spots.

You can tell NICREW thought about the practical side, ensuring every inch of your tank receives optimal light.

Adjusting the intensity is straightforward, thanks to the intuitive controls and the USB-C ports. The ability to connect to external controllers means you can customize lighting schedules to match your coral’s needs perfectly.

The mounting options are versatile—whether hanging or using arm mounts, it’s flexible enough to fit your setup. Plus, the minimal noise from the fan is a relief, especially if your tank is in a living space.

Overall, this fixture offers a mix of power, customization, and sleek design that makes reef keeping easier and more enjoyable. It’s a solid investment if you want bright, healthy corals with a beautiful glow.

VIPARSPECTRA 165W LED Aquarium Light Dimmable Full Spectrum

VIPARSPECTRA 165W LED Aquarium Light Dimmable Full Spectrum
Pros:
  • Precise dimming control
  • Full spectrum lighting
  • Easy remote operation
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Manual controls could be better
Specification:
Light Spectrum Full spectrum with proprietary layout optimized for coral growth
Coverage Area Approximately 24 inches x 24 inches
Power Consumption 165 Watts
PAR Output Scientifically balanced for optimal photosynthesis
Dimming Capability Adjustable brightness on two channels from 0% to 100%
Control Method Manual control knob and remote control

The first thing that hits you when you turn on the VIPARSPECTRA 165W LED Aquarium Light is how smoothly you can dial in the perfect brightness. The dimmer controls are responsive and allow for precise adjustments, which makes acclimating new corals or tweaking existing setups a breeze.

The full spectrum design really stands out. It’s clear that a lot of thought went into the layout, especially with input from seasoned reef keepers.

The light provides vibrant, natural colors that make your corals pop—no dull or washed-out hues here.

Setting up the light is straightforward, whether you choose to use the control knob or the remote. I appreciated the flexibility—sometimes I just want to tweak settings manually, other times I want everything automated.

The internal timer worked flawlessly, turning the light on and off according to my schedule.

The coverage area is spot-on for a 24″x24″ tank. The light distribution is even, avoiding hotspots or dim spots.

I also tested the gradual light increase feature, and it helped prevent stress to my corals during acclimation.

Overall, the build feels sturdy, and the sleek design blends well with most aquariums. Plus, the full spectrum and dimming features give you the control needed for healthy coral growth and vibrant displays.

It’s an excellent investment for serious reef hobbyists who want reliable, customizable lighting.

NICREW HyperReef 200 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 200W Reef

NICREW HyperReef 200 Gen 2 Reef LED Light, 200W Reef
Pros:
  • Excellent spectrum for corals
  • Even PAR distribution
  • Quiet, efficient heat management
Cons:
  • Higher price point
  • Requires external controller for full features
Specification:
Light Power 200W
Spectral Range Enhanced violet and blue spectrum for coral growth and fluorescence
Optical System Custom wide-angle optical system for extensive coverage and even PAR distribution
Heat Management Advanced heat dissipation with a new fan and redesigned heatsink for minimal noise
Control Interface 2 USB-C ports for external controller connectivity
Mounting Options Multiple mounting systems including single arm, hanging kits, and other configurations

Ever since the NICREW HyperReef 200 Gen 2 landed on my radar, I’ve been curious about how it truly performs in a real reef setup. When I finally got my hands on it, I was immediately impressed by how sleek and robust the design feels—solid aluminum heatsink, and a quiet, efficient fan that barely makes a sound.

The first thing I noticed was the spectrum. The blend of violet and blue LEDs is clearly tuned for coral growth, and the fluorescence this light sparks is pretty stunning.

It covers my tank evenly, thanks to that custom wide-angle optical system, which eliminates hotspots and gives a nice, consistent PAR distribution across the entire reef.

Adjusting the light was a breeze with the USB-C ports, especially since I connected it to my external controller—making custom schedules and intensities super simple. The build quality is excellent, and the heat management is impressive; I didn’t notice any excessive warmth even after hours of operation.

The multiple mounting options are a real plus, letting me hang it or use the arm setup depending on my tank’s needs. The light’s intensity and spectrum make a noticeable difference in coral coloration and growth.

Honestly, it feels like NICREW has thought of everything to deliver a professional-grade reef light that’s user-friendly and powerful.

Overall, this light lives up to its promise. It’s a top-tier choice if you’re serious about reef keeping and want an LED that’s customizable, efficient, and effective.

NICREW NavaReef 135 Reef LED Light, 135W Reef Aquarium

NICREW NavaReef 135 Reef LED Light, 135W Reef Aquarium
Pros:
  • Focused wavelength for fluorescence
  • Quiet, efficient cooling
  • Easy to control and mount
Cons:
  • Additional hanging kit sold separately
  • Slightly higher price point
Specification:
Wattage 135W
Wavelength Focus 440-480nm for coral fluorescence and growth
Beam Angle 90° adjustable lens optics
Cooling System Near-silent fan with heat dissipation
Control Options Built-in timer and external controller compatibility
Mounting Compatibility Supports standard tank mount and optional hanging kit

From the moment I powered up the NICREW NavaReef 135, I noticed how clean and compact the design is compared to other reef lights I’ve handled. Its sleek, black enclosure with a removable dust-resistant mesh gives it a polished look, and the adjustable mounting options make it versatile for both rimmed and rimless tanks.

The real standout is how intensely focused the light is at the 440-480nm wavelengths. I immediately saw a vibrant glow on my coral, with fluorescence popping in a way I haven’t seen with other fixtures.

The custom 90° beam-angle lenses concentrate the PAR output perfectly, especially in deeper tanks where light penetration is often an issue.

Controlling the NavaReef is straightforward thanks to the built-in timer and compatibility with external controllers. I appreciated how quiet the cooling system runs—almost silent—yet it keeps the LEDs cool even after hours of use.

The heat dissipation feels efficient, meaning it won’t overheat or require frequent adjustments.

Setting it up was a breeze, thanks to the included tank mount, which fits rimmed and rimless tanks effortlessly. The build quality feels solid, and the adjustable intensity lets me fine-tune the lighting for different coral species.

Overall, it’s a powerful, well-designed fixture that delivers impressive coral growth and fluorescence enhancement without wasting energy.

SMATFARM 140W Reef Aquarium Light with Timer & Group Control

SMATFARM 140W Reef Aquarium Light with Timer & Group Control
Pros:
  • Powerful 140W output
  • Easy group control
  • Quiet operation
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Heavy for hanging setup
Specification:
Maximum Power Output 140 Watts
LED Configuration 52 high-power 5W LEDs across six channels (White, Blue, Violet, Ultraviolet, Green, Red)
Control System Wireless 2.4G master-slave group control with touch and remote operation
Lighting Modes Pre-programmed SPS/LPS mix modes with sunrise, sunset, and moonlight simulation
Heat Dissipation Full-coverage aluminum heatsink with super silent smart fan, noise level below 40dB
Installation Options Sturdy oxidized aluminum bracket for glass tanks from 0.2″ to 1.5″ thick or hanging mount

As I reached for the SMATFARM 140W Reef Aquarium Light, I was immediately struck by its sturdy aluminum build and sleek design. The touch screen OLED display feels intuitive, and I couldn’t wait to see how smoothly I could control the lighting.

Setting up the light was surprisingly simple. The adjustable mounting brackets fit securely on my tank, and the hanging option gave me flexible installation choices.

When I powered it on, the 52 high-power LEDs lit up with a bright, natural glow that immediately made my corals pop.

The real magic started when I used the group control and timer functions. It was effortless to synchronize multiple lights and set sunrise-sunset cycles.

The six channels allow me to customize the spectrum precisely—white for daylight, blue and violet to enhance coral fluorescence, and UV for health.

The fan is whisper-quiet, and I barely noticed it running even after hours of operation. The full-coverage heatsink keeps the temperature stable, so I don’t worry about overheating.

I also appreciated how easy it was to adjust the dimming in 1% increments—perfect for mimicking natural lighting.

Overall, this light feels like a professional-grade upgrade for my reef tank. It’s powerful, flexible, and user-friendly, making my coral keeping experience much more enjoyable.

Plus, the customer support from SMATFARM has been reassuring, especially with their training group and quick responses.

What Is the Importance of Proper Lighting for Coral Health in Reef Aquariums?

Proper lighting is crucial for coral health in reef aquariums. It provides the necessary spectrum of light for photosynthesis, which is how corals obtain energy from symbiotic algae, known as zooxanthellae. Without adequate lighting, corals may struggle to thrive and grow.

According to the Marine Conservation Society, “Corals rely on light for the crucial photosynthetic process that sustains them.” This organization emphasizes that appropriate lighting mimics natural sunlight conditions needed for coral ecosystems.

Various aspects of lighting importance include light intensity, duration, and spectrum. Different coral species require specific light conditions, and inadequate lighting can lead to coral bleaching, reduced growth, and poor health. Corals with insufficient light may expel their zooxanthellae, leading to a decline in their health.

The University of Florida Extension defines adequate lighting as providing a balance of blue and white light. This spectrum promotes both coral growth and algae health, supporting the entire reef ecosystem. The right lighting can prevent stress-related diseases in corals.

Factors contributing to poor coral health include inadequate light intensity, incorrect light spectrum, and inconsistent light duration. Without proper conditions, coral reefs can experience declines in biodiversity and ecosystem stability.

Research from the Coral Triangle Initiative indicates that 30% of coral species may decline under low light conditions, threatening marine biodiversity and fisheries, and potentially impacting tourism revenues.

The wider impacts of proper lighting extend to ecosystem health and economy. Healthy corals support marine life, tourism, and fishing industries, which are vital for coastal communities.

Addressing lighting issues includes implementing LED lighting systems that mimic natural sunlight. The Aquarium Conservation Partnership recommends using full-spectrum LED lights for optimal coral growth.

Specific strategies involve using timers for consistent light cycles and monitoring coral growth to adjust lighting as necessary. Utilizing proper light management practices can enhance reef aquarium success and coral health.

How Do LED Lights Compare to T5 and Metal Halide for Aquarium Reef Lighting?

LED lights, T5, and Metal Halide are popular choices for aquarium reef lighting, each with distinct characteristics:

FeatureLED LightsT5Metal Halide
Energy EfficiencyHighModerateLow
Heat OutputLowModerateHigh
Lifespan25,000-50,000 hours15,000-20,000 hours10,000-15,000 hours
Light SpectrumFull spectrum availableGood spectrum but limitedExcellent spectrum for growth
CostHigher initial investmentModerateLower initial investment
InstallationEasy to install, no special fittingsRequires specific fixturesRequires specific fixtures and cooling
Color Rendering Index (CRI)High (80-95)Moderate (70-90)High (80-90)
MaintenanceLow maintenanceModerate maintenance (bulb replacement)High maintenance (bulb and cooling system)

Each lighting type has its advantages and disadvantages, making the choice dependent on specific aquarium needs and preferences.

What Specific Features Should You Look for in High-Quality LED Reef Lights?

High-quality LED reef lights should have specific features to ensure optimal growth and health of corals and marine life.

  1. Full Spectrum Light
  2. Adjustable Light Intensity
  3. Energy Efficiency
  4. Cooling Technology
  5. Programmable Settings
  6. Good Build Quality
  7. Quality Brand

Considering diverse perspectives, one could argue that while full spectrum light is essential for coral growth, some aquarists may prioritize energy efficiency or brand reputation over light spectrum specifications. Each feature plays a critical role, yet individual needs may differ based on the size of the aquarium, type of corals, or specific lighting preferences.

  1. Full Spectrum Light: Full spectrum light refers to a light source that emits wavelengths across the entire visible spectrum, from violet to red. This ensures that corals receive all the necessary colors for photosynthesis and growth. Research shows that certain corals benefit from specific wavelengths, making full spectrum lights highly desirable. For instance, the blue spectrum, around 420-480 nm, supports coral growth and vibrant color expression.

  2. Adjustable Light Intensity: Adjustable light intensity allows users to customize brightness levels based on the specific needs of reef inhabitants. Different corals require varying light levels for optimal health. According to a study by O. Leal et al. (2021), providing adjustable light can significantly enhance coral growth and reduce stress, making this feature crucial for maintaining a healthy reef ecosystem.

  3. Energy Efficiency: Energy-efficient LED lights consume less electricity than traditional lighting options, reducing operational costs. Energy-saving benefits not only lessen the environmental impact but also make maintaining a reef aquarium more affordable over time. The U.S. Department of Energy states that switching to LEDs can reduce energy use by up to 75%, contributing to sustainable aquarium practices.

  4. Cooling Technology: Effective cooling technology prevents overheating, which can damage both the lights and the aquarium ecosystem. Quality LED reef lights often incorporate heat sinks or fans to dissipate heat. Poor heat management can lead to equipment failure and harm to sensitive marine life, according to recommendations by the Marine Conservation Society.

  5. Programmable Settings: Programmable settings permit aquarists to create specific lighting schedules, mimicking natural daylight cycles. This feature enhances the well-being of corals by providing consistent lighting patterns. A study by G.J. Meijer et al. (2022) highlighted that scheduled lighting reduces stress on reef inhabitants, leading to healthier ecosystems.

  6. Good Build Quality: Good build quality ensures durability and longevity of LED reef lights. Saltwater environments are corrosive and can affect equipment over time. High-quality materials and water-resistant features are essential. Many aquarists report that investing in better build quality can lead to fewer replacements and maintenance issues.

  7. Quality Brand: Choosing lights from reputable brands offers assurance of performance and support. Established brands often provide better warranties and customer service. Reviews and user experiences indicate that brand reputation can significantly influence lighting choices, leading to more satisfactory results overall.

How Does Light Spectrum Impact Coral Growth and Coloration?

Light spectrum impacts coral growth and coloration in several ways. First, different wavelengths of light promote various biological processes in corals. For instance, blue light supports photosynthesis more effectively than other wavelengths. Corals harbor zooxanthellae, a type of algae that performs photosynthesis. This process provides energy to the coral and influences its growth.

Second, light intensity plays a crucial role. High light intensity can enhance coral growth by stimulating photosynthesis. However, excessive light can lead to coral bleaching. Bleaching occurs when corals expel zooxanthellae, losing their color and essential nutrients.

Third, the color of light affects coloration in corals. Some corals develop vibrant colors under specific light spectra. For example, red and green light can enhance the fluorescence of certain coral species, making them appear more colorful and attractive.

Fourth, light quality influences the overall health of coral reefs. The combination of different light spectra affects the diversity of coral species. A balanced spectrum promotes a rich ecosystem, supporting various marine life.

Lastly, light exposure duration is significant. Corals require a specific photoperiod, or length of light exposure, for optimal growth. Too little light slows growth, while too much can damage the coral.

Overall, the light spectrum serves as a critical component for coral growth and color. Proper light conditions support healthy coral ecosystems in aquariums and natural environments.

What Are the Installation and Maintenance Considerations for Reef Aquarium Lighting?

The installation and maintenance considerations for reef aquarium lighting include several factors that impact the health of marine life and overall tank aesthetics.

  1. Types of lighting
  2. Placement and positioning
  3. Control systems
  4. Energy efficiency
  5. Maintenance routines
  6. Light spectrum requirements

The lighting type you choose significantly influences your reef’s ecosystem.

  1. Types of lighting:
    The type of lighting refers to the various technologies available for aquarium illumination. Common types include LED, fluorescent, and metal halide lights. LED lights are energy-efficient and have a long lifespan. Fluorescent lights are suitable for beginners, while metal halide lights produce intense brightness for deeper tanks. Each type has its benefits and drawbacks.

  2. Placement and positioning:
    Placement and positioning refer to how lights are arranged above the aquarium to optimize light distribution. Proper positioning ensures that all corals and organisms receive adequate light. Lights should be placed to avoid direct glare and minimize shadows. Adjustable mounting is recommended for larger tanks.

  3. Control systems:
    Control systems manage lighting schedules and intensity. Timers and programmable controllers allow for the simulation of natural daylight cycles. This promotes coral growth and maintains the health of the aquarium. More advanced systems may offer spectrum adjustments for specific coral needs.

  4. Energy efficiency:
    Energy efficiency relates to the power consumption of lighting options. Choosing energy-efficient lighting reduces costs and environmental impact. LED lights, for instance, consume less energy than traditional lighting, making them a popular choice among reef aquarium enthusiasts.

  5. Maintenance routines:
    Maintenance routines involve regular checks and cleaning of lighting equipment. This includes replacing bulbs or adjusting light intensity as needed. Regular maintenance extends the lifespan of the lighting system and ensures optimal performance.

  6. Light spectrum requirements:
    Light spectrum requirements refer to the specific wavelengths of light needed for coral and marine life health. Different corals thrive under various light spectrums. For example, blue light promotes growth, while red light can enhance coloration. Understanding these requirements is crucial for effective reef aquarium management.

By carefully addressing these considerations, you can create a thriving and vibrant reef aquarium environment.

How Can You Optimize Your Aquarium Setup for Ideal Reef Lighting Conditions?

To optimize your aquarium setup for ideal reef lighting conditions, focus on the right light spectrum, intensity, duration, and lamp placement.

The light spectrum: Choose lighting that provides a full spectrum range, ideally between 400 nm to 700 nm. This range supports photosynthesis in corals and encourages healthy growth. Studies, such as one by C. J. H. brachyura (2019), indicate this spectrum enhances coral health.

Light intensity: Select lights with adjustable intensity to match your specific reef needs. For coral health, maintain light levels between 150 to 300 µmol/m²/s at the coral level. Overexposure can lead to bleaching, while insufficient light can stunt growth.

Lighting duration: Set the lighting cycle to mimic natural conditions, with a duration of 10 to 12 hours of light followed by total darkness. This cycle helps maintain the circadian rhythms of reef inhabitants. Research by K. D. Jones (2021) notes that consistent light duration promotes coral spawning behavior.

Lamp placement: Position lights at appropriate heights above the water surface. This height allows uniform light distribution to all corals. With LED fixtures, a distance of 12 to 24 inches is effective for both intensity and coverage, as indicated by T. R. Elaine (2020).

Regular maintenance: Clean the light fixtures every few weeks to maintain optimal performance. Dust and algae can reduce light output, affecting coral growth and health.

By addressing these aspects, aquarium enthusiasts can create an ideal environment for their reef inhabitants.

What Are the Key Benefits of Upgrading to Modern LED Systems Over Traditional Lighting?

The key benefits of upgrading to modern LED systems over traditional lighting include energy efficiency, longevity, lower maintenance costs, better light quality, and environmental sustainability.

  1. Energy Efficiency
  2. Longevity
  3. Lower Maintenance Costs
  4. Better Light Quality
  5. Environmental Sustainability

Upgrading to modern LED systems provides various advantages. Each benefit can significantly impact user experiences when contrasted with traditional lighting methods.

  1. Energy Efficiency:
    Energy efficiency of LED lighting refers to its ability to produce the same amount of light using less electricity compared to traditional incandescent bulbs. LEDs use about 75% less energy than incandescent lights, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. This reduction in energy consumption can lead to substantial cost savings on electricity bills, which is attractive to both residential and commercial users. For example, a business that switches to LED lighting can save over $1,000 a year in energy costs through lower consumption.

  2. Longevity:
    The longevity of LED systems signifies their extended lifespan compared to traditional lighting alternatives. LEDs can last up to 25,000 to 50,000 hours, significantly outlasting incandescent bulbs, which typically last around 1,000 hours. This longevity reduces the frequency of replacements, which is beneficial for places like street lighting or commercial buildings where access can be challenging. The reduced need for replacements leads to lower operational costs and less waste.

  3. Lower Maintenance Costs:
    Lower maintenance costs associated with LED lights arise from their durability and longevity. Fewer replacements mean lower labor costs and less disruption for businesses and homeowners. Additionally, reduced downtime is particularly advantageous for commercial settings, such as retail stores, where consistent lighting is crucial for customer experiences. Studies show that switching to LED can result in maintenance savings of up to 80%, particularly in high-use environments.

  4. Better Light Quality:
    Better light quality refers to the ability of LED systems to produce a consistent, high-quality light that enhances visibility and color rendering. LEDs offer options in color temperature, which allows users to choose warm or cool lighting that fits specific needs. Improved light quality enhances the ambiance in homes, stores, and offices. Research conducted by the Lighting Research Center states that well-lit environments can improve mood and productivity, making LED systems a preferred choice.

  5. Environmental Sustainability:
    Environmental sustainability of LED lighting pertains to its reduced environmental impact. LEDs do not contain hazardous materials, such as mercury, found in fluorescent bulbs. Additionally, their high energy efficiency lowers carbon emissions associated with electricity generation. The EPA notes that widespread adoption of LED lighting could save the country more than $30 billion in electricity costs annually, decreasing our carbon footprint and contributing to a more sustainable environment.

Overall, these benefits illustrate why upgrading to modern LED systems is becoming a preferred choice for many consumers and businesses.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment